Stunk, Zel, Kanchal, and Crimvael head to the Gender Swap Inn to get in touch with their feminine sides. Zel gets into a sticky situation with a slime girl. Crim goes on safari with a well-endowed hyena girl.

The Reviewers visit a brothel filled with insatiable succubi, which they soon come to regret. Later on, they try visiting a heated-up brothel of salamander women.

The Reviewers visit a cyclops brothel. Later on, they try out a myconid brothel filled with mushroom girls.

The Reviewers visit a golem brothel that allows them to build their own girl, but get in trouble when they copy the appearance of a close friend. Later on, they visit a will-o'-the-wisp brothel, where the girls give off light.

The Reviewers go to a brothel where the girls lay eggs. Later on, they attend a ceremony that reveals the most popular girl species.

The Reviewers try out a brothel focusing on roleplay. Later on, they visit another succubi brothel.

While making a delivery to Count Delivel the vampire, Stunk, Zel and Bruise are introduced to an undead brothel, offering everything from zombies to vampires. Back at home, Crimvael visits a magical slime brothel by himself. Later, the gang discover some reviews written by a different group of reviewers, including one of a lesbian joint by a female film director named Bina Banana.

The reviewers arrive in the Magic Metropolis, where their money allows each of them to spend three days doing whatever they want with a decoy doll based on the Archmage Demia. As the reviewers find the benefits of their experience go beyond just the usual service, the real Demia takes a particular interest in Crimvael's unique properties.

An incubus takes offense to the reviewers' negative reviews, taking it upon himself to review these establishments himself and give them all perfect scores, although his bragging is cut short when a vengeful lover stabs him. After an arrangement with the Porter Guild and the rival reviewers pays huge dividends, the gang get drunk and go to an leprechaun establishment for succu-girls on top of more alcohol.

The reviewers finally visit the demon brothel they were originally supposed to review during the election. They are given special treatment due to the nature of how demons abide to contracts. Meanwhile, Demia meets up with the demon lord Death Abyss, discussing what things are like in a world without magic.