The boys go on a stakeout to uncover the mystery of the missing shopping carts and come face-to-face with notorious cart rustler Bloodbeard.

Peanut discovers that Pickle never learned to swim and takes him to the local pool for lessons. Meanwhile, Peanut falls in love with the swimming lesson instructor, to which he is later teamed up with Wayne.

Pickle wants a falcon so he can join the local falconry club, but Peanut acquires a parakeet from Sneaky Patty (voiced by Abbi Jacobson) instead. Both are later challenged to a falcon battle with Wayne.

Pickle is excited to win a family of creatures as a cereal box prize, but the creatures start multiplying rapidly and prove too much for Pickle and Peanut to handle.

Pickle and Peanut accidentally break Mjärt Mart's new automated checkout machine, the PAL-SCAN, but they brought the machine back to life after fixing it.

Peanut enters Pickle in a local mall contest to find the new face of America's Sweetboy Taffy.

Pickle and Peanut's friendship is tested when they conjure up the terrifying ghostly ghoul, Gory Agnes, and Pickle begins dating her.

After accidentally breaking Pickle's couch, the boys purchase a new one from Couch Dracula's but soon discover that the replacement couch is cursed.

Pickle and Peanut cannot afford a bottle of the body spray they are fixated on so they make their own.

The boys are desperate to buy a pair of the cool Turkey Wrap Headphones made by their favorite rapper D-Stixx, so they start a car service to earn extra money. Rapper Kool Keith guest stars as D-Stixx.

When Pickle bakes his grandma's delicious cookies for the neighbors, a troupe of little girls called the Sugar Bees compete with the boys to defend their turf.

Pickle's cast earns him some newfound popularity, so Peanut fakes a broken limb to get some attention.

The boys find "Pigfoot" – a portmanteau of a pig and Bigfoot – while (painfully) playing paintball with McSweats.

Pickle and Peanut visit Lazer's karate class, but Peanut is horrible at it, while Pickle is great at it. However, when a herd of goats wreak havoc (and the boys find out that the karate class is a fake), Pickle and Peanut must save the day.

The boys find a shark in the sewers and are eaten by it.

The boys, unhappy that Christmas is over, start a new holiday: "Cabbage Day".

The boys turn Christmas time back into springtime.

The boys have a snowball fight and find a "yellow snowball" that is set on wrecking the town.

Pickle goes on vacation with his family and puts Peanut in charge of his bees.

Pickle loses sleep over the relentlessly barking dog next door.

Peanut attends a renaissance faire hosted at the Pizza Slop.

Pickle and Peanut get teased at the local Y.

Pickle and Peanut find their favorite cartoon character at a yard sale. Shaquille O'Neal guest stars as 90's Adventure Bear.

Pickle loses one of his shoes on a carnival ride.

A big volcano is about to erupt.

YouTube star, Bike Jumper, breaks his leg after Pickle suggests a dangerous jump.

McSweats' girlfriend Francine breaks up with him, so Pickle and Peanut try their hand at couple counseling.

Pickle and Peanut make a cell phone tree their own hut.

Sneaky Patty hides out the night at Pickle's house.

After losing his last baby tooth, Pickle sprouts a full grown beard.

Pickle and Peanut's van becomes infested with bats.

Pickle and Peanut camp out overnight in the mall to catch the first showing of a new movie.

Pickle and Peanut volunteer to work all night stocking the shelves at Mjart Mart.

The boys buy scalped tickets to go see Pickle's favorite band.

Pickle and Peanut dig up the carpet at Pickle's house and discover something fun and destructive.

Peanut and the Rat King trade places.

When Peanut's uncle's uncle leaves him an inheritance, he and Pickle must cross the Australian Outback in order to retrieve.

The boys get busted for Lazer for a trick-or-treating like little kids.