As the eliminated men acclimate to their new surroundings, those still standing get wet and wild – in a water balloon dodgeball competition. While the winners blissfully bask in alone time with the ladies, game-changing secrets are revealed back at the cottages. Then, elimination takes the nice guy vs. fboy debate to shocking new heights.

CJ, Sarah, and Nakia’s attempt to sharpen their fboy radar is immediately thwarted by the arrival of three new suitors. After an impromptu photoshoot tests the men’s chemistry with our leads, a bro-down showdown devolves into chaos, leading to an elimination where no one is safe.

The elimination’s shocking reveal sends Garrett scrambling to make up lost ground with Sarah, while CJ and Casey navigate the fallout of their own blossoming relationship. Then, a dance-off helps lighten the mood, giving the ladies an opportunity to explore their physical connection with the remaining suitors.

A surprise double-elimination provides the remaining suitors with space to grow closer to the women. But later, Nakia, CJ, and Sarah’s fun attempt at testing how well the men have been paying attention is suddenly derailed by the threat of an altercation.

With their true colors revealed, the nice guys revel in their elevated status, while the fboys struggle to redeem themselves. After the ladies get exclusive access to their suitors’ social media pages, Sarah issues an ultimatum, CJ gives someone new a shot, and Nakia returns to her comfort zone.

The surprise return of a familiar face inspires two happy reunions... while simultaneously upending life in the cottages. CJ, Nakia, and Sarah are forced to choose between their remaining suitors for 2-on-1s, before all of the men must plead their cases at elimination.

Gunning for a spot in one of the ladies’ top two, the guys suit up for a wet and wild pool party. After a trip to Stingray City adds a little extra bite to the competition,Casey and Garrett make a Bro Pact –and later, Sarah, CJ, and Nakia must decide which of their remaining suitors will advance to the final dates.

In a shocking turn of events, the former denizens of LimBRO and Nice Guy Grotto return to spill every last drop of tea on the remaining suitors. After a no-holds-barred “Mansplain” reunion, the ladies go on the first of their epic 24-hour dates... while those left behind hope they’re not being edged out of the competition.

The ladies dissect the explosive reunion before going on their second 24-hour date with the remaining FBoys, who are desperate to prove they’ve been reformed by their time on the island. Then, with love and $100,000 at stake, Nakia, CJ, and Sarah seal their fate in the jaw-dropping final elimination round to decide which suitor will accompany them off FBoy Island.